Can you keep livebearing boys together without girls?

Egglayers keep out!
Rhys
Posts: 5
Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2009 10:47 am
Location:
Contact:

Can you keep livebearing boys together without girls?

Post by Rhys »

Whenever I read on how many to keep together it's always so the boy doesn't wear the girls out. So does that mean I can keep a lot of guys together without problems?
dennysfishroom
Posts: 3142
Joined: Fri Apr 06, 2007 8:47 am
Location: Garfield, Arkansas
Contact:

Re: Can you keep livebearing boys together without girls?

Post by dennysfishroom »

Lot's of people do just that. Normally you shouldn't have any problems. Denny
If it was easy, anyone could do it!
User avatar
mewickham
NWAAS President
Posts: 2680
Joined: Sun Mar 15, 2009 12:50 am
Location: Rogers, Arkansas
Contact:

Re: Can you keep livebearing boys together without girls?

Post by mewickham »

That's actually how they raise the fancy guppies on the Asian farms. The fish grow faster and when they select specimens to breed, they can be sure which male breeds with which female. Livebearer females can store sperm and have more than one batch of babies from a single mating, so this is the only way to be sure who the father is.

It's not wise with all livebearers, though. Male swordtails are quite competitive and fare poorly when crowded. Many hobbyists discover that they lose all their male swordtails until only one is left. Juvenile males swordtails, especially some of the rarer species, may delay development of their swords when kept in the aquarium with other males.

Young platy fry, kept in crowded conditions are more likely to develop into males and mature at a smaller size. This is Mother Nature's way of controlling overpopulation. Fewer females and smaller, less-competitive males, means fewer new fry to continue the crowding.
Mike Wickham
http://mikewickham.com
NWAAS Webmaster, Publicity Chair
Post Reply